myricky1

I'm using MG07 14TB and it's also not noisy
pc1668 發表於 2022-3-23 01:46

嘈唔嘈真係因人而異, 太多因素影響
-係咪木耳
-住天橋對出, 定三四十樓以上/對內園/郊區
-HDD放邊度, 距離對耳幾遠. 例如放係廰SOFA底, 理論上隻HDD嘈到拆天都乜人覺得嘈, 但房係睡房兩三尺距離就唔同
-放係NAS定靜音厚機箱
-會唔會24小時運作, 日間背境聲一定大D, 所以無咁覺. 如果晚晚都通頂運作, 夜瀾人靜個陣就會特別覺得嘈

computer1975

用緊MG08 12T 害氣版靜過之前買的MG05 8T空氣版

via HKEPC Reader for Android

rfdingo

用緊mg07, mg08既師兄

mg06我之前用，其實接受到 d 明顯讀寫時既卡卡聲
但我接受唔到佢閒時  摩打重低音持續震動既聲
想問mg08 係咪都仲有呢類聲？

*mg05都 amz 有個review 有講
https://www.amazon.com/Toshiba-1 ... /dp/B07DHY61JP?th=1
Great value, but noisy enough to wake the dead
The humming sound can only be described as a constant booming base note that is felt rather than heard and whenever the drives were accessed the sound is like a deep thrum that resonates around the room.

KinChungE

用緊mg07, mg08既師兄

mg06我之前用，其實接受到 d 明顯讀寫時既卡卡聲
但我接受唔到佢閒時  摩打重低音持 ...
rfdingo 發表於 2022-3-23 13:59

你當He碟聽落細聲一半, 但係唔會冇聲

kean23

覺唔覺He碟好似輕過空氣碟?

aes090

你當He碟聽落細聲一半, 但係唔會冇聲
KinChungE 發表於 2022-3-23 15:44

  可唔可以咁講:  氦氣技術硬碟運作時嘈音會細聲d

KinChungE

可唔可以咁講:  氦氣技術硬碟運作時嘈音會細聲d
aes090 發表於 2022-3-23 22:02

只能講, 氦氣碟係密封, 所以D聲焗住響入面
空氣碟唔係密封, 所以入面震會易D傳出黎

alanh999

回覆 23# rfdingo


   Toshiba enterprise HDDs are usually nosier than WD, Seagate etc.
You won't expect Toshiba to do much to dampen such noise as true enterprise customers don't care. Their server rooms are already very noisy.

7個提供

比較 :

NAS 裡面的東芝 4T's，加埋都唔夠封印機箱入面隻 MG08 企業版大聲
不過 MG08 真係快，可能 512M cache

aes090

用靜音機箱:
剛買Toshiba 16TB 全力運轉係會有風扇聲 但唔係好覺
舊Toshiba 4TB 全力運轉係會有轟隆...轟隆...咁既聲 相當明顯 (係咪就黎壞先會咁?)
舊Toshiba 2TB 無咩聲

16TB版 速度真係勁快260MB/s 寫入