標題: [外置硬碟] Western Digital My Passport Ultra 新版 定係 舊版 好？？ [打印本頁]

---

作者: oscar2    時間: 2016-2-4 16:49     標題: Western Digital My Passport Ultra 新版 定係 舊版 好？？

Western Digital My Passport Ultra  新版 定係 舊版 好？？

---

作者: anon893    時間: 2016-2-4 17:26


None of them, really

---

作者: oscar2    時間: 2016-2-4 17:43

回覆 2# anon893

姐係咩意思???   新舊版冇分別~?

---

作者: pc1668    時間: 2016-2-4 18:02

Western Digital My Passport series is prone to failure

---

作者: klshiu    時間: 2016-2-4 20:53



Any other suggestions then?

---

作者: pc1668    時間: 2016-2-4 20:58



I'm using StoreJet 25H3

http://www.transcend-info.com/Products/No-324

---

作者: P800    時間: 2016-2-5 00:14




This one is good and with a 2TB (WDC?) inside it.

Should I buy 25H3 2TB or buy a StoreJet 25S3 case a 2TB HDD separately? It looks like24H3 is even cheaper.

---

作者: pc1668    時間: 2016-2-5 08:46

本帖最後由 pc1668 於 2016-2-5 08:49 編輯


I'm using 2TB 25H3 and 2TB 25A3.  Very stable.

Getting the StoreJet 25S3 case a 2TB HDD separately would be more flexible.  However, the cost would be higher (as expected).

What is 24H3 ?

---

作者: anon893    時間: 2016-2-5 16:12

回覆 7# P800
Cheaper is not always better
If you plan to get enclosure and HDD separately, note that only Samsuck Spointpoint M9T offers the 2.5" in 2TB

---

作者: anon893    時間: 2016-2-5 16:17


MyA$$port Ultra is only available as 新版
舊版 is simply called MyA$$port

And if you insist on having a definite answer, then all I can say is that 舊版 (or rather, 舊 design) is more flexible since the very old ones don't employ bridge boards with embedded USB3 interface

Not convinced?  Do your homework please

---

作者: P800    時間: 2016-2-6 00:07

回覆 8# pc1668

sorry typo, I was mentioning 25H3.

---

作者: 1597532468000    時間: 2016-2-6 00:45

我用緊果隻幾年前既seagate freeagent goflex有得將個usb 3.0 adapter拆出黎換做esata或者firewire 800 adapter
不過我將部hdd當左internal咁用
個adapter用左黎插其他2.5" hdd/ssd

張圖n年前影

---

作者: 1597532468000    時間: 2016-2-6 00:48

唔知e+仲有冇出呢類hdd...
不過ext. hdd自己搵盒仔有得你揀hdd好過買現成

---

作者: pc1668    時間: 2016-2-6 10:03



it seems Samsuck hdd is not that good ... prone to bad sectors and premature failure

---

作者: oscar2    時間: 2016-2-6 15:05

已購買StoreJet 25H3  2TB

---

作者: anon893    時間: 2016-2-6 17:56


Oh, sorry to hear
Heard bad things on Samsuck-branded Suckgate, but not too aware of this

Unfortunately WD never offers Caviar Blue (or Black) in 2TB, otherwise I would've forgotten the Spinpoint M9T for good

---

作者: anon893    時間: 2016-2-6 17:58


IMO you should remove the outer enclosure and let the HDD sit bare inside the tower case, for better heatsinking

---

作者: pc1668    時間: 2016-2-6 21:45



excellent